July 21, 2008
(Quotations from Evans' original text in 
. . .
The second structure equation of Cartan is:
                
Ra = D Ù ωa = 
d Ù ωa + 
ωacÙ ωc
                
                      
(1.5)
 
better written as
 
                
Rab = 
d Ù ωab + 
ωacÙ ωcb
                
                
                
(1.5')
. . .
The first identity of Cartan geometry is:
DÙTa := RabÙ qb (1.7)
. . .
Finally the second identity of Cartan geometry is a restatement of the second structure equation:
                
DÙRa = DÙ(DÙ ωa) 
                
                
                
(1.11)
 
better written as
 
                
DÙRab = 
DÙ(DÙωab)
                
                
                
(1.11')
Note that for a Christoffel connection, i.e. if and only if the torsion vanishes, Eq.(1.11) becomes
                
DÙRab = 0
                
                
                
                
(1.12)
  The problem is that Evans' New Math does not know the Poincaré formula 
dÙd = 0 (simply forgotten), and hence Evans cannot understand
the proofs for DÙRab = 0 
that are folklore of literature.
 [1] M.W. Evans, APPENDIX 10: REBUTTAL OF G. BRUHN'S COMMENTS 
 [2] F.W. Hehl, Y.N. Obukhov, Foundations of Classical Electrodynamics − 
 [3] G.W. Bruhn, Remarks on Evans' paper #100 - Section 2.,
Eq.(1.12) is always true, for general torsion, not only for a Christoffel connection. 
See e.g. F.W. Hehl's and Y.N. Obukhov's book [2, p.208] or G.W. Bruhn's 
web-note [3, Sect.2].
Where is the problem?
References
   
ON THE LORENTZ COVARIANCE OF THE B CYCLIC THEOREM, 
   
Part of web-paper #89,
       
http://www.aias.us/documents/uft/a89thpaper.pdf
   
Charge, Flux and Metric,
   
Birkhäuser 2003, ISBN 0-8176-4222-6, ISBN 3-7643-4222-6
       
http://www2.mathematik.tu-darmstadt.de/~bruhn/onMwesPaper100-2.html
 
HOME